Film
Room Serviceable
Suite-natured Sundance favorite founders on indie clichés
by Michael Atkinson
June 27th, 2006 2:43 PM
The Motel
Written and directed by Michael Kang
Palm, June 28 through July 11, Film Forum
be social
'Norbit'
Tracking Shots by Rob Nelson
'Close to Home'
Tracking Shots by Ella Taylor
'Bridge to Terabithia'
Tracking Shots by Jessica Grose
'Antibodies'
Tracking Shots by Ed Gonzalez
'Coffee Date'
Tracking Shots by Michael Fox
The Re-Education of the Hipster
Fly Life by Tricia Romano
Dangerous Dildos, Part 2
Pucker Up by Tristan Taormino
Anna Nicole Was Not a Whore!
La Dolce Musto by Michael Musto
What a Relief! It's Cold!
Sutton Impact by Ward Sutton
China: Partner in Genocide
Nat Hentoff by Nat Hentoff
Bush's Decisive New Strategy for Victory!
This Modern World by Tom Tomorrow
Hardly a native flowering of extra-mainstream vision these days, American indies are trapped in a ghetto of second-class homogenization, less pandering than Hollywood but just as conservative. The little-people semi-stories, colorless dialogue, stiff-legged acting, sniffly amused middle-class soundtracks, deficit of visual intelligence: It's a cinema its own lower-middle-class characters would find dull and patronizing, not due to narrative asceticism but for the lack of ambition or imagination. The Motel, Michael Kang's modest Sundance applause reaper, doesn't deserve to be shotgunned for the sins of 30 other movies. But the underwhelming syncopation of make-nice clichés is too familiar. Based on a novel by Ed Lin, Kang's film is a pubertal dramedy centered on Ernest (Jeffrey Chyau), a Chinese American 13-year-old junk-foodie who works as a maid at his mother's backwater motel. There he impassively finds discarded porn, hangs with a 16-year-old waitress (Samantha Futerman), puts up with bullies, argues with his regally ferocious mother (Jade Wu) about a writing contest he entered, and learns about irresponsible loitering from a lonely Korean American whoremonger (Sung Kang) who leaves only to pick up booty and booze.

Kang shot his film in Poughkeepsie, but the locale has been anonymized, and the blind tumble into banality is easy and inevitable. ("I hate you!" Ernest eventually hollers at his hard-case mom; "You need me!" Ernest is told by his new hooker-loving pal; "I don't need anyone!" is the reply.) If The Motel circles around to a single effective moment of generational confrontation amid the sulking, credit should perhaps go to Wu, expertly limning out the script's most interesting character by far, a fearless immigrant woman we first see busting down a goldbricker's door with a baseball bat. She radiates experience, which is more than can be said about the filmmakers. Michael Atkinson

More by Michael Atkinson
Breathless Pop Filmmaking
Lady Vengeance

Vivid and Zesty: Old-School Feminist Emancipation
The Girls

'. . . So Goes the Nation'

A Supremely Odd and Strangely Serene Fantasy
Dust Devil

Life Is Sweet
With its seventh installment, Michael Apted's drama of aging approaches a half-century
49 Up

news
blogs
music
film
people
nycguide
nyclife
arts
screens
tags