Skip to main content

Taylor Swift unknowingly crowned this red scarf the must-have of the season. Want one just like it?

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. 

If you'd ask us in 2012 that the one topic of discussion on everyone's mind in 2021 would still be "where is Taylor Swift's red scarf?" and specifically, "who has it?" chances are no one would believe it. But here we are, nine years later, and the mystery is still bridging the gap between Swifties and experts alike, with investigations ongoing.

Popular celebrity-gossip account DeuxMoi revealed on Instagram that not only has the account verified the authenticity of the scarf (it does exist), but after receiving a tip, they made contact with her team. Meaning the scarf could be on its way back to her at this very moment.

Tackle your holiday shopping with deals and expert advice delivered straight to your phone. Sign up for text message alerts from the deal-hunting team at Reviewed.

Whether that is true or not, the conversations continued on Twitter, with legendary singer Dionne Warwick entering the chat. 

"If that young man [Jake Gyllenhaal] has Taylor's scarf, he should return it," she says. "It does not belong to you. Box it up, and I will pay the cost of postage, Jake," she adds in a second tweet.

Between Warwick and the entire world searching for this scarf, it's bound to reach Taylor eventually. Right? It's unclear — but what is clear is that red scarfs are in higher demand than ever, and now's the time to get in on this season's most-talked-about accessory. 

►Scarf's Version: It's me, Taylor Swift's scarf. I'm here to tell my side of 'All Too Well' (Scarf's Version)

►More: Taylor Swift's new 'Red' is a fan feast of 30 sensitive, angry and transformative songs

What does Taylor Swift's red scarf look like?

After investigating, Taylor's open-stitch scarf is categorically correct, falling under the red column, but it appears to be more of a berry or wine hue. The distinct shade is far darker and much deeper than the traditional tomato red tone but differentiates itself with enough lightness to stay clear from a burgundy label. 

In short, we know all too well, this scarf, much like Taylor, will be impossible to replicate, and that's where we come in.

From chunky to cashmere styles, we found eight ready-to-wear red scarfs that not only mimic Taylor's missing version but are available as soon as today. 

1. A designer red scarf

Logo lovers rejoice as this is the red scarf for you. Echoing the same deep red Taylor Swift prefers, this shade strikes a balance between dark and light and hits it out of the park with a cherry red coloring. In fact, it continues to impress, adding Coach's signature 'C' logo to 14% of the scarf; it's just the right amount of logo to make this scarf wearable regularly. Factor in the 100% wool material to keep us warm and consider us all sold. 

Get the Signature Oblong Scarf from the Coach Outlet for $63.20

2. A gender-neutral scarf

This gender-neutral Autumn Burgundy scarf from Old Navy is 67-inch long, a.k.a. large enough to fit any neck size (and wrap around more than once), plus the 100% cozy acrylic material keeps you warm and toasty. We're sure Taylor wouldn't be able to resist all 11 of the other shades and styles. 

Add in the fringed edges and the fact that it's gender-neutral, and we can't help but agree with the reviewers who are "quite pleased" with this perfect piece. 

Get the Cozy Flannel Scarf from Old Navy for $12

3. A dip-dyed red scarf

Sure, this red scarf deters a bit from Taylor Swift's signature style, but can you blame us for including it? Available in a wine and midnight navy variation, this dip-dyed piece creates a striking ombré effect, and the 54-inch piece features a soft, lightweight cotton-and-wool blend. Perfect for everyday wear, we're partial to the perfectly portioned square silhouette that can fold up and fit into your bag when living life on the go. 

Get the Signature Ombre Oversized Square Scarf from Coach for $117

4. A red scarf that doubles as a blanket

If the thought of leaving your beloved blanket in the morning is something you can no longer bear to do, then this red scarf is calling your name. At 78', this versatile scarf can double as your new winter staple; drape it around your shoulders like a blanket during your day, and transition it into nighttime as a scarf. Deemed "the most luxurious pashmina scarf" by shoppers, the 70% cashmere and 30% cotton blend is so snuggly soft that you'll want all 12 of the available shades. 

Get the vinmate Store Cashmere Scarf from Amazon for $39.99

5. A thin red scarf

For those who prefer a slimmer scarf, this one is the perfect investment piece. Durable and warm, the subtle ribbing detail throughout is ideal, just as its merlot hue is highly favored. Crafted from 100% soft sustainable Mongolian cashmere, the buttery-soft design is available in 12 shades, all of which will make a perfect gift for anyone in your life this year.

Get the Signature Ribbed Cashmere Scarf from naadam for $125

6. A classic red scarf

Elevate every day with this 100% cashmere scarf. With a soft-to-touch feel, fringed edges, one-size-fits-all and 11 different shades up for grabs, it's safe to assume this piece will be a staple in your wardrobe for years to come. 

Get the Cashmere Classic Scarf from Theory for $195

7. A budget-friendly friend scarf

A 100% acrylic scarf for under $20, could it be? It most certainly can. With this hand-woven choice, you'll make sure you remain warm and cozy all day, every day. Plus, the unexpected red hue blended with the subtle tassels on the edges is a stylish substitution for outdated browns and blacks.

Get the ASOS Design Supersoft Tassel Scarf from ASOS for $17.50

8. An oversized red scarf

Naturally, we saved the best for last: this chunky merlot scarf. With this piece, you will stay cozy and stylish during even the worst winter storms, and with the 70' x 5' length, you can accessorize it in a variety of ways. With a chunky wool blend yarn, it's bound to be just as beloved as Grandma's handmade blanket. 

Get the Chunky Wool Blend Scarf from Etsy for $28

Don’t get thwarted by shipping delays or sold-out favorites this holiday season. Sign up for our free weekly newsletter to get shopping tips, deals, product reviews, gift guides and more.

The product experts at Reviewed have all your shopping needs covered. Follow Reviewed on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok or Flipboard for the latest deals, product reviews and more.

Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.